Using RTOS for NIOS 2

[Altera_Forum]

Hi all, 

 I'm wondering if there are any significant advantages of using RTOS in FPGA compared to RTOS in hard core microprocessor.  regards, Michael

[Altera_Forum]

Hi Michael, 

   --- Quote Start ---   I'm wondering if there are any significant advantages of using RTOS in FPGA compared to RTOS in hard core microprocessor.   --- Quote End ---  As far as processor cores go, there is no major difference between an FPGA soft-core processor, an FPGA hard-core processor, or an external processor chip.   Whether or not you can get the performance you require is a processor selection issue. For example, if you need 50MHz performance, a NIOS or external microcontroller would work. However, if you need 1GHz performance, you might want an external processor, or a newer generation FPGA with 1GHz hard-IP processor.  Whether or not you run an RTOS is purely up to you. If processor cost is an issue and you need to maximize the CPU usage, then an RTOS is a good way to go (though an RTOS can be expensive too). If cost is less of an issue, time-to-market is important, or you want to maximize programmer availability, then an external processor running Linux might be the way to go.  For example, I have a large DSP-based system that runs uCOS-II (~70% CPU usage), and I have to make all the code changes. I have another large PowerPC-based system running Linux (~20% CPU usage), and there are other programmer resources that can deal with code maintenance.  As far as FPGA real-estate goes, I have yet to buy off on the advantages of a Linux-class processor in an FPGA. This type of processor needs DDR memory, Flash, RTC, etc., which consumes pins on the FPGA. My applications tend to be I/O bound, so I cannot afford to lose those pins. A PowerPC processor with a high-speed SERDES, or serial RapidIO interface costs very little in terms of FPGA pin use, and the processors themselves are ~$100 (Freescale PowerQUICC II/III processors).  You'll have a different set of design decisions, but that gives you a few things to think about.  Cheers, Dave